Hmmmm....
I usually spend some time contemplating my response before firing back, but I've waited long enough...
The only reason my original comment about EMS not being for dabblers is because the OP, in his original statement, (or let me say I inferred from his OP) left me with a feeling that he is not really interested in EMS as a profession in and of itself, but rather, that he is looking for something he can do as something easy on the side.
I'll accept that you inferred...
Do you think that EMS is in any aspect, easy, or fair game for people who don't see it for what it is... EMERGENCY CARE...?
Absolutely, do think it's rocket surgery?
The EMT-B job is so easy that it can be taught and executed using simple commands, and even simpler techniques... It's a certificate that can be gained with minimal hands on time, a high school diploma and/or GED, and a short class. (coincidently, I don't think this is right, but rather my opinion of the current state of affairs)
So you think that someone who gets 120 hours of education and admits that they have no interest in or time to continue education or certification should be encouraged to join this industry?
I think that everyone should have a starting place. I also have also seen some of my best EMTs fall into the field by accident, i.e. extra time, need a job, etc... Do you believe that they should have a burning desire to be Johnny and Roy?
You think we should welcome with warm arms providers who may not have it in their heart to do the job 100%... Do you think that patients might receive a lesser standard of care, if they are treated by providers who are only interested in this as a part-time-temporary gig?
To extend your logic, how do you feel about volunteers... (they are only interested in it as a part time gig... They do it to help, but don't make a profession out of it...) Do you feel they might provide substandard care? I don't think that any profession should welcome a prospective employee who does not commit to perform their duties to the best of their abilities, including serving my fries at McDonalds... I however do see the possibilities of someone who wishes to work at this as a job until they can achieve their personal goals.
(*edited to add this comment*) And specifically to address your welding comment... If you feel the emt-b certificate is just a blow-off, do you want to perpetuate that perspective by encouraging the disinterested to join the ranks of new emt-b certs?
Yes, I think that everyone should get first aid certified... And yes, the EMT-B is a blowoff. I fail to see the logic in teaching someone a series of motions, without the knowledge to back up what they are doing. I get fresh EMTs continuously, who can backboard someone, but can't tell me why they are doing it. They can splint, but can't tell me the reasons why you would, or would not splint a fracture. Their A&P is pathetic, and they lack a competant ability to think through the mechanics of trauma on a body, much less the ability to explain to me why they are doing what they are doing. That is an educational FAILURE. That's just injured, lack of understanding of illness is even worse... I believe in further education for our profession, and raising the standards. However, raising standards will weed out the profession, and I'd rather have as big of a pool of applicants and potential interest as possible when that time comes.
my final thought, if you just wanted a free ski pass, why do you frequent the forum... you must admit you do have some interest in the field of EMS...
My final comment... I started because I wanted a free ski pass, what I didn't mention is that I have spent several years in various EMS specialties, and also am an EMS Instructor, Field Trainer, and currently EMS management...