Dog Intubation

G

Gilbert

Forum Ride Along
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Hey all, I am in a paramedic class right now and the instructor just told us that we will be intubating a dog to get our field intubations required by the state of Michigan to get our license. I am irritated to no end with the thought of getting my "tubes" with a dog. A: because im a dog lover B: because its not even close to a human. I think this is a cheap way of getting out of having to deal with the hospitals and the operating rooms...and I think it's a load of crap. What do you all think?
PS the last class that intubated the dog said that there wasn't a single surgery that day for any animal so the Vet. brought her dobermin for them to intubate the dog was intubated 50 or so times in one session I have a huge problem with that as well. Am I missing something?
 
Gilbert said:
Hey all, I am in a paramedic class right now and the instructor just told us that we will be intubating a dog to get our field intubations required by the state of Michigan to get our license. I am irritated to no end with the thought of getting my "tubes" with a dog. A: because im a dog lover B: because its not even close to a human. I think this is a cheap way of getting out of having to deal with the hospitals and the operating rooms...and I think it's a load of crap. What do you all think?
PS the last class that intubated the dog said that there wasn't a single surgery that day for any animal so the Vet. brought her dobermin for them to intubate the dog was intubated 50 or so times in one session I have a huge problem with that as well. Am I missing something?
Click to expand...

Um where the heck are you going to school? There's no clinicals???

Is that even legal?
 
Much of medicine is learned on lesser species before trying it on humans. Take the opportunity to learn.
 
yes there are clinicals and we also have to pass an externship. The company is solid.
 
I've never heard of such a thing...!
 
Many schools use dogs, cats, goats, etc to help you develop proper techniques.
 
I'd have problems with the intubating a dog repeatedly in one session because there would be too high a chance for injury upon extubation in my opinion.

As for the anatomy, it's close enough that you can learn the techniques and more importantly - get over the fear of intubation. If your state has a minimum required intubations, I can understand using this as an option (otherwise you may have bad luck and be waiting for months just for your last intubation).

I think you should have done better research before picking that course if you have that much of an issue with the way they operate.
 
We intubated goats and ferrets during school. The goats got put down afterwards (they had many different skills performed on them), but the ferrets were reused.
 
I am irritated to no end with the thought of getting my "tubes" with a dog. A: because im a dog lover
Click to expand...

I like animals much more than I do people but don't see a problem with this.


I'd have problems with the intubating a dog repeatedly in one session because there would be too high a chance for injury upon extubation in my opinion.
Click to expand...

Most are euthanized before or after the practice session. We used several freshly euthanized dogs and cats to allow enough practice for everyone in a reasonable amount of time. This was in addition to OR time and intubations during our clinicals.

B: because its not even close to a human.
Click to expand...

You know that old "Better to remain silent and be thought a fool...." adage?

We used cats as their anatomy- minus the teeth of course- is very similar to a small child's both in layout and size and dogs because it's not that far off from a human adult's once you get past the muzzle (in a flat nosed breed like a pug or mastiff, it's honestly pretty similar) and the principles of intubation are the same regardless.
 
My girlfriend is a vet, and I just told her about this thread. She laughed, "Dogs are easy," she said. "if you want to simulate pedi airways, try kittens." I advocated using cats as a training adjunct for pedi intubations in a paper that I wrote for medic school.
 
If it's a well run program it's not as bad as it sounds.

My medic class went to a very reputable college that had a cat intubation lab. The cats were rescues that were put through the anesthesia process to be spayed/neutered and to see how they would tolerate it. If they came through that with flying colors they were used for the intubation lab a maximum of two sessions with many months required between the sessions. After the cats had fulfilled their two sessions they were adopted out with a very careful background examination of the household and were open for us to adopt as well. During the intubations there was a vet and 2 vet techs watching us at all times to make sure we were being careful and using good technique. After every couple intubation attempts the vet and the techs would examine the cats vocal chords before proceeding with more attempts to make sure that they were not showing signs of injury. If they were the cats were pulled into recovery immediately. These cats would very likely have been euthanized in the shelters that they were acquired from and instead went on to be spayed/neutered and live in an awesome cat house with toys and things to climb on with college students to play with them daily before finally being adopted out. I should mention that all of this is monitored by a strict internal review board as well.

I'm a huge animal lover and even I couldn't find any real reason to be against this program. I'm so thankful for the experience of intubating an airway that small before someone's baby is thrust into my arms requiring intubation. If it's a well run program take the opportunity. It's not a human but it may be the closest approximation you get before you're out there doing this in emergency situations.
 
n7lxi said:
My girlfriend is a vet, and I just told her about this thread. She laughed, "Dogs are easy," she said. "if you want to simulate pedi airways, try kittens." I advocated using cats as a training adjunct for pedi intubations in a paper that I wrote for medic school.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I've intubated quite a few dogs over the course of my career thanks to seeing them pulled from burning buildings, etc. I'd rather intubate any dog over your average person any day.
 
We didn't intubate dogs, but we did do cats. They were all given ketamine prior to the session, and there were only 2 students per cat. After we each intubated the cat 2 or 3 times, the cats were taken back to their cages and monitored until the ketamine wore off. Afterwards, we were given the opportunity to adopt them.
 
Were it not for dogs, we wouldn't have CPR and defibrillation.

They were the first animals chosen to be worked on. The earliest recognition that closed cardiac compressions maintains blood pressure was on dogs. The way external cardiac defibrillation along with CPR was "sold" to skeptical MD's in the late 1950's was fibrillating the dog, intubation and CPR begun, de-fibrillating the dog and then letting the dog get up, walk around and exhibit ROSC.

If all goes as planned, I'll be telling the story in our February Newsletter.

Were it not for dogs being man's best friend, you'd still be load and go.
 
I'm sitting here, envisioning an OPA for dogs, and trying not to giggle. I think maybe I'm just tired and need some rest.... :P
 
firetender said:
W
They were the first animals chosen to be worked on. The earliest recognition that closed cardiac compressions maintains blood pressure was on dogs. The way external cardiac defibrillation along with CPR was "sold" to skeptical MD's in the late 1950's was fibrillating the dog, intubation and CPR begun, de-fibrillating the dog and then letting the dog get up, walk around and exhibit ROSC.
Click to expand...

It's funny how this stuff works. I also love animals, and would have a very hard time working on dogs.

Yet I don't have similar problems with pigs. Which are almost certainly more intelligent. But we consider them a food animal, not a companion animal, so it seems to be more acceptable to use them for this sort of research.

I can only echo the comments of other's here, that the vet's I've talked to have said that dogs are easy intubations, you just grab the tongue and jaw together, pull a bit, and the cords should present. I guess most have a pretty good Mallampatti. :)
 
my old partner was a Navy Corpsman. he said part of their training involved learning how to intubate pigs.

supposedly if you can intubate a pig, a human is MUCH easier
 
would have a very hard time working on dogs
Click to expand...

I'd much prefer we got to practice on prisoners and others with a debt to society to repay but unfortunately some :censored::censored::censored::censored::censored::censored::censored:s about 70 years ago completely ruined that option.

you just grab the tongue and jaw together, pull a bit, and the cords should present. I guess most have a pretty good Mallampatti.
Click to expand...

The fact that their mouth normally lines up perfectly with their trachea explains a lot. ;)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top