Prehospital command hierarchy, fitting it in with the regular medical community

SmokeMedic said:
Well, I don't know where you work but I'm sorry you have such a low opinion of EMS. Half of the students in my class have bachelors and 75% have associates. Some of them have degrees in biology and other medical related sciences. EVERYONE in my class has taken college level A&P I & II, Psychology, and Microbiology. Plus almost everyone has been on the street as EMT's for a minimum of 1 year most have several years of experience. I'm not sure how you are equating all of this school and experience as undereducated.....Don't take one apple out a barrel and call the whole barrel bad
Click to expand...
Maybe because the fact that such programs exist? And a good amount at that.
 
Katy said:
I'm not sure they surpass the LPN's in that area either.
Click to expand...

Maybe I don't know to be honest with you, all I can go on is my limited knowledge. I do know that EMT's where I work can start intravenous lines, perform assessments of OB, Geriatric, and Pediatric patients, as well as several other invasive procedures all on standing orders and without supervision. Again, not necessarily saying surpass, but probably equal. Now I don't argue that a LPN has significantly more understanding of A&P, patient care(esp longterm) and pathophys than the average EMT.
 
SmokeMedic said:
Maybe I don't know to be honest with you, all I can go on is my limited knowledge. I do know that EMT's where I work can start intravenous lines, perform assessments of OB, Geriatric, and Pediatric patients, as well as several other invasive procedures all on standing orders and without supervision. Again, not necessarily saying surpass, but probably equal. Now I don't argue that a LPN has significantly more understanding of A&P, patient care(esp longterm) and pathophys than the average EMT.
Click to expand...
I'm pretty sure in the state of Colorado the EMT-B must be I.V. certified to do some of those things. If the LPN is certified, he/she can do all of the above and I bet more. And LPN's can assess patients, and are especially trained in focused and initial ones. Most of the time they are checked off or signed by the RN. Correct me if I am wrong though.
 
Katy said:
Maybe because the fact that such programs exist? And a good amount at that.
Click to expand...

I know that my school produces outstanding medics, has a 100% first time pass rate on NREMT, and have the respect of patients, ER docs, and peers when working the streets.
 
SmokeMedic said:
I know that my school produces outstanding medics, has a 100% first time pass rate on NREMT, and have the respect of patients, ER docs, and peers when working the streets.
Click to expand...
Like you said earlier, you can't take an apple out of the barrel and judge the whole barrel based on that one. Your program is what we strive for, but sadly they aren't a standard practice.
 
SmokeMedic said:
Well, I don't know where you work but I'm sorry you have such a low opinion of EMS. Half of the students in my class have bachelors and 75% have associates. Some of them have degrees in biology and other medical related sciences. EVERYONE in my class has taken college level A&P I & II, Psychology, and Microbiology. Plus almost everyone has been on the street as EMT's for a minimum of 1 year most have several years of experience. I'm not sure how you are equating all of this school and experience as undereducated.....Don't take one apple out a barrel and call the whole barrel bad
Click to expand...
That's great (even though I personally don't care about the year of experience bandaid fix to limited time). However, there are plenty of schools in California that turn out paramedics at the minimum 1000 hours without any serious pre-reqs (oh, wait, a 4-5 day A/P for Paramedics program).

One bad apple spoils the bunch. The problem with EMS is that it isn't just one bad apple.
 
JPINFV said:
If the nurse has an issue with nursing care, in contrast to medical care, they aren't going to call the physician for orders. Additionally, they aren't going to call just because they're scared about liability. Personally, I think the "I'm not sure if the patient who's A/Ox4 and has capacity can sign AMA, so I'm going to call medical control just in case, and that way the liability is on them" type of call is nothing more than a -false- sense of security.

I don't want to have physicians riding on every ambulance. I want the people who are providing care on an ambulance to be able to have the foundation to make decisions and justify those decisions without using medical control as a "I'm scared of the dark, and medical control is my blanky."

Furthermore, it's not even appropraite to compare a nurse calling for orders to a paramedic. The ward nurse more often than not is calling the patient's personal physician, who personally knows the patient, has examined the patient, and knows what the patient's current treatment plan is and why, where the medical control physician only knows what the paramedic thinks is important to tell him.

Oh, and if EMTs aren't professionals, then they need not be on an ambulance without direct supervision. If paramedics are a profession, then they, as a whole, need to start acting like it, including demanding a proper education.
Click to expand...

Your being a little dramatic don't you think? I mean who calls a doc to see if a pt is AA0X4? Thats what a mental assessment is for. And you are saying that using Med Control is a crutch but that is the exception not the rule....most medics use Med Control for what its for....to obtain orders that exceed protocols and/or to get a higher and more educated opinion when the situation requires it. Rarely is it used to 'just get the load off my back' as you are implying....
 
SmokeMedic said:
I know that my school produces outstanding medics, has a 100% first time pass rate on NREMT, and have the respect of patients, ER docs, and peers when working the streets.
Click to expand...

Google the phrases "statistical outlier" and "anecdotal evidence".
 
JPINFV said:
That's great (even though I personally don't care about the year of experience bandaid fix to limited time). However, there are plenty of schools in California that turn out paramedics at the minimum 1000 hours without any serious pre-reqs (oh, wait, a 4-5 day A/P for Paramedics program).

One bad apple spoils the bunch. The problem with EMS is that it isn't just one bad apple.
Click to expand...

WOW...you have a really low opinion of EMS. Whats your experience? Im seriously curious...one state? Since California does EVERYTHING right :rofl:
And give me a break with the more than one bad apple.....your saying that there is a such a higher ratio of bad medics to good ones compared to say bad nurses or doctors to good ones? Show me some statistics or evidence other than your limited opinion?
 
Katy said:
Like you said earlier, you can't take an apple out of the barrel and judge the whole barrel based on that one. Your program is what we strive for, but sadly they aren't a standard practice.
Click to expand...

Your point is valid, I just don't think it's quite as bad as people are making it out to be. You do still have to pass NREMT. Granted its just a test but it does say something.......
 
SmokeMedic said:
Your point is valid, I just don't think it's quite as bad as people are making it out to be. You do still have to pass NREMT. Granted its just a test but it does say something.......
Click to expand...
Also granted that the majority of Paramedics who had a halfway decent program and actually learned stuff thought it was relatively easy. Most people consider the NREMT a "joke" in regards to its difficulty.
 
Katy said:
Also granted that the majority of Paramedics who had a halfway decent program and actually learned stuff thought it was relatively easy. Most people consider the NREMT a "joke" in regards to its difficulty.
Click to expand...

Haha true.....All I can do is work hard everyday to be the best Medic I can be. I hope if I run into any of these EMS 'haters'(on this EMS board btw) I can prove them wrong and show them what a good Medic is all about. I am a little surprised that current Paramedics haven't joined in this conversation.
 
SmokeMedic said:
Haha true.....All I can do is work hard everyday to be the best Medic I can be. I hope if I run into any of these EMS 'haters'(on this EMS board btw) I can prove them wrong and show them what a good Medic is all about. I am a little surprised that current Paramedics haven't joined in this conversation.
Click to expand...
I wouldn't consider them haters, you may sometimes see them as "harsh" because they are being critical of a career they care about. Tough love.
 
Tigger said:
Citation please, the Rule 500 that I read from states that basics can push frontline cardiac meds during an arrest only, and nothing else.

I will see if I can find it. And you may be right about frontline cardiac meds but as far as I know for most meds(maybe cardiac ones as well) if the Paramedic tells them to push it then they can. Again, you may be right.


Are there any reasons in favor of EMS not interacting with a physician more? I mean honestly it can only lead to the betterment of EMS given that we need the MD's help to advance. In order for MDs to really trust their EMS providers (and I know it does happen, just not where I am), we are going to have you know, actually talk to the doctor now and then.

Also think twice about RNs only being able to implement procedures and interventions or asses a patient without an MDs orders. I've seen and been a part of codes worked at Penrose in C Springs where the ED physician was not present for any length of time. Everything went smoothly with only a few RNs, Techs, and RRT. A
Click to expand...

ER RN's are another breed. Truly professionals and I have been impressed with almost all that I have met. One of the ER RN's at Penrose is a mentor of mine and if I could be half the Emergency Medical clinician that he is I would be immensely proud.
 
Katy said:
I wouldn't consider them haters, you may sometimes see them as "harsh" because they are being critical of a career they care about. Tough love.
Click to expand...

Eh...I'm feeling a lot more hate than love or constructive criticism. And none of them are Paramedics so I don't really understand where their expertise is coming from other than observations in their limited area. It'd be like running into a couple burnt out RT's, Nurses or Doc's and saying that most Doc's, Nurses or RT's in the country don't know what they are doing. Pretty thin
 
SmokeMedic said:
WOW...you have a really low opinion of EMS. Whats your experience? Im seriously curious...one state? Since California does EVERYTHING right :rofl:
And give me a break with the more than one bad apple.....your saying that there is a such a higher ratio of bad medics to good ones compared to say bad nurses or doctors to good ones? Show me some statistics or evidence other than your limited opinion?
Click to expand...

SlIYw.png
 
SmokeMedic said:
RN's that are not really part of emergency medicine or a similar discipline aren't even close to Medics in their freedom, medical skills, or judgement making abilities.
Click to expand...
Honestly, this is hard for me to believe. What about a good ICU nurse? Or a nurse working in a Pediatric floor? These RN's must have good judgement making skills and medical skills.
 
Katy said:
Honestly, this is hard for me to believe. What about a good ICU nurse? Or a nurse working in a Pediatric floor? These RN's must have good judgement making skills and medical skills.
Click to expand...

I don't know, maybe I have to eat some humble pie because of my foot in mouth. I'm sure they have OUTSTANDING judgement making and medical skills....they still get direct orders from a doc on their floor........
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top