Can we create a sticky and place the following links in it?
http://emtlife.com/showthread.php?t=20619&highlight=boots
....
lots of links
....
http://emtlife.com/showthread.php?t=2356&highlight=boots
Not a knock on you, YCALR. I'm glad you decided to search.
This thread should obviously have gone in the appropriate equipment-related subforum, but anyways. It got me thinking. Maybe the following deserves its own post, but here goes. Commence braindump:
The same thing comes up repeatedly with 2 main topics (and several others, with less frequency): boots and stethoscopes. Creating a sticky is a fair idea, but I'm not sure it will really solve the problem. There are a couple issues at play here. First, people are lazy (myself included). A lot of these older threads are many pages long, with a huge number of redundant/repeated posts. Every steth thread mentions the Ultrascope, there's always debate about Littmanns, etc. It's usually easier and quicker for a user to repost an old topic and get a response than to go searching through old threads.
Additionally, as I just stated, a lot of the threads are just that - old. There is no real way to keep links current or redact information that is no longer relevant (i.e., when a popular boot is discontinued) other than creating new threads/posts. The stethoscope sticky alone would probably be a dozen pages before it was a month old (which feeds back into the first problem regarding too much clutter to sift through to get actual answers).
A better solution than a sticky might be some kind of in-house wiki or dedicated page. Have a mod/CL pool together information and be responsible for keeping it up to date. At best, you would need a short paragraph for each item, and maybe a link or two. A few esteemed forum members (medicRob, for example) could submit reviews and such. Relevant questions could be pruned from other threads and pulled in, as simple Q + As (omitting the 3 pages of inside jokes, +1s, and trolling). That way, there is one central, always updated place that a user can go looking for information on boots/steths/pants/whatever.
Hell, maybe you'll even be able to get vendors to start sending you equipment samples to review. I'm not aware of too many sites that do reviews of this stuff, and certainly none focused on use by pre-hospital providers.