Search results

  1. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    No, he was talking about your car as the responder. Also, the no entrapment was on the driver, not the passenger.
  2. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    Authority having jurisdiction
  3. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    Except in situations where, as the NFPA puts it, the environment is immediately dangerous to life and health. EX: burning building, burning car, etc. Of course then, you'd be justified if you refused to help from a scene safety standpoint. I'm hoping you caught that much of what you...
  4. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    Just one that I forgot to ask before - What color underwear was the good Samaritan wearing? :p
  5. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    I'm with Cory, completely. It's risk/benefit, plain and simple. I positively abhor the culture of danger that pervades EMS and oftentimes Fire, but there is a difference between thinking danger is "cool" and knowing that you are entering a potentially dangerous situation with the purpose of...
  6. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    Phew. You had me reaaaally worried there. For the record... Look at the "smoke" (powder) color in the bottom right corner of this picture: Compared with the smoke color in this picture: It's pretty easy to tell which one is from an airbag. Generally speaking, nothing on fire these days is...
  7. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    I sure hope not. That object is occluding blood flow and saving the patient's life. Removing it will kill the patient. There's a damn good reason that in every EMT and medic class you take - as well as any fire class - they will tell you NOT to remove an embedded object. No offense man...
  8. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    I dunno, if approaching at night and not immediately noticing the leaking fluid, I'm thinking more along the lines of what I was taught for HAZMAT: calculated risk. If there's a good chance of rescuing a savable life, then that's worth some risk.* Plus, if the car catches, the driver is...
  9. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    Okay, but that wasn't the scenario. The scenario was that you were off-duty, just driving by, and that is what you have. Otherwise, I'd have a jump bag with me, along with various short-term and long-term wilderness survival items, etc etc.
  10. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    I guess if you want to split hairs, clear and colorless are two different things. If it's summer, it could be condensate from the A/C; it could also be the working fluid from the A/C, possibly brake fluid, engine oil if newly changed, engine coolant, WW fluid (AS YOU said), etc etc etc. I'm...
  11. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    Nice catch, Sandog. A couple more questions about the impalement: Color of the blood? Quantity? Quality? Any other fluids? By right in the middle, do you mean (essentially) the navel? What kind of pain is he in from the impaled object? Somewhat unrelated question: what kind of car...
  12. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    Absolutely 100% agreed. The butt of a knife would work, or the tool kit in your car (EVERY car these days has them - for changing flats and such). There's a lot of things that can break tempered glass if you know where to hit it. Try the metal pointy part of your headrest. Agreed - but my...
  13. S

    Good Samaritan - Rescue Vs. Medical

    I know there are some here would say they'd never stop. I'm not one of them, so whatever. For brevity/clarity, I'll say the driver is male and the passenger is female. First, call 911 - of course. Would mention being off-duty EMS/fire (well, that is, once I graduate as fire II in 2 weeks)...
  14. S

    EMT Disarms Patient

    I'm with everyone else: there was a MASSIVE lapse of judgment when the patient was allowed to leave unsupervised.
  15. S

    Good Samaritan shot for stopping to help

    I say again: let's get back on topic. Start a new thread if you want to argue about this. I would be very glad to address the personal... attacks you've levied at me, but this is NOT the place to do it. And, furthermore, we've been warned by a mod. I, for one, am immensely saddened to hear...
  16. S

    Good Samaritan shot for stopping to help

    (emphasis changed) A rose by any other name. I'm not saying you incapacitate him and then shoot him again. My point is, shooting someone in the hand to knock away the gun is NOT shooting to eliminate the threat. Nor is that easily defensible in court. If a police officer or lawyer asks...
  17. S

    Good Samaritan shot for stopping to help

    Ah, but there's more to it than that. It never said he got in his truck with the intent of killing Piper. He was just looking for Piper. If your next door neighbor were shooting something inside his house and you heard/saw, and wanted to check it out, wouldn't you bring a gun with? I sure as...
  18. S

    Good Samaritan shot for stopping to help

    Personally, assuming the linked article is correct, I think this is much more a +1 for the knowing when to act side. "Neighbor John Swartz put his wife and son in their basement, grabbed his gun and got in his truck to look for the man. He said he saw Raymond Piper walking along Route 981, so...
  19. S

    Southside Virginia Emergency Crew EMT stops police chase with ambulance - EMT Charged

    How about we all think of this a different way. What is the number 1 rule in EMS? ... ... You got it, scene safety. You can't help anyone else if you turn yourself into a patient. That applies equally to your conduct in the squad as it does your on-scene arrival. Whether or not...
  20. S

    Southside Virginia Emergency Crew EMT stops police chase with ambulance - EMT Charged

    Might have meant side mirror. But either way, to be honest, I'm a little conflicted: on the one hand, unlike police cruisers, ambos are NOT meant to be crashed. On the other hand, looking at the damage to both, this couldn't possibly have been much more than a 40-mph chase... I guess the...
Top